30 Comments
User's avatar
Marissa's avatar

I think it makes a lot of sense that fiction that appeals to Boomer readers is selling, while memoirs that appeal to millennials are getting lots of library check-outs but fewer sales! Like Lindy West, I'm an elder millennial, and I'm somewhat curious as to what all the hype is about but also going "will this book really stand the test of time? Does it merit a permanent space on my overstuffed bookshelves in my 1-bedroom apartment, or can I just get it from the library?"

Jim Hanas's avatar

In the case of Lindy West -- and probably Olivia Nuzzi -- I would wager that audio units were higher than print units. That is the typical shape of celeb memoir now.

Lincoln Michel's avatar

Your wager is correct (as someone at the publisher just told me).

Jim Hanas's avatar

… out the door to buy a lottery ticket.

Tobias Carroll's avatar

Alas, I may never get the chance to write THE DRAGON HAD ABS.

Val Stuart 🌻's avatar

Oh, you can still write it. It sounds timeless.

Libbie Grant's avatar

THANK YOU, omg. The way this industry relies on BookScan as the god of all data drives me up a wall, when WE ALL KNOW it does NOT give a complete picture of actual sales.

And it's particularly annoying right now, when anyone at any publisher could use Claude to code an app that allows them to scrape *real, actual sales data* to get a complete picture of a book's or author's track. But they won't do that, because "we've always done it this way."

This industry makes me insane.

Carla Conti's avatar

What a great breakdown, Lincoln, thank you!

Lisa Sumner's avatar

I just finished reading Metallic Realms and I can’t stop thinking about it. I love the cover on the cover on the Owl Crate edition. I guess writers might as well give up on figuring out what “sells” since by the time you are finished writing everything will have changed….

Lincoln Michel's avatar

Ah, thank you so much! (And yes, I don’t try to write to the market. It changes so quickly.)

Sally Ekus's avatar

What a valuable explainer for people!

Alicia's avatar

This is really helpful to know—thanks for sharing!

Adam M. Rosen's avatar

I am eagerly awaiting the Dragon Smoochers, Lincoln.

Portia's avatar

Me too. I'd read anything by Lincoln, I'm sure his grocery list is a riveting read.

Nick Mamatas's avatar

NB: Bookscan's claim is that they have visibility on 85% of the places where books are sold (basically cash registers), which isn't quite the same as 85% of sales.

Lincoln Michel's avatar

Ah that's a good note. Their website description is misleading then: "Point-of-sale tracking for the publishing market, covering approximately 85% of trade print books sold in the U.S."

Nick Mamatas's avatar

Right, the trick is trade there. So special sales—for example, remember when Urban Outfitters would carry books, but also gift shops for local attractions, toy stores and baby clothes stores, fancy cookware shops etc.—are all out.

David Perlmutter's avatar

Thank you for this tutorial...

Nikki's avatar

I just read The Correspondent for a book club I’m in. The next book that was chosen is… Theo of Golden haha. I enjoyed the first and am currently enjoying the second of these books, but I will probably suggest something other than a heartwarming late in life transformation book as a palate cleanser for our next read.

Elizabeth Penney's avatar

My book scan numbers are always way below what my royalty statements say, and it's not all e books. My mystery sales are 3/4 print.

Lincoln Michel's avatar

At least in part those are probably sales to stores pre-returns, and also library sales

Elizabeth Penney's avatar

No, I'm talking sales after returns. Earned out, too. Also, in mass market paperback, so very few library sales. I use my royalty statements to talk about sales.

Brooke Warner's avatar

Helpful info for authors. I also wonder when and whether bookscan could start to track audiobook sales. I basically only listen to audio for anything new—including Lindy West's book, which was very good. And couldn't agree more about the disparity between discourse and sales. Everyone has an opinion on books they don't intend to read, especially when it comes to memoir.

Rubber's avatar

My novel The Beautiful Ones was moved to a romantasy imprint (Bramble, part of Tor) and has a new cover to position it in this category.

Richard Donnelly's avatar

"1,800 copies in a week is a lot of books... the majority never sell that many at all." That's if you include small and self publishers. A Big 5 novel will sell.