Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michelle Richmond's avatar

Terrific conversation. Thanks so much. I finished my MFA just a few years after John and a few years before you, Lincoln. One thing that was similar then as now is that the best path to publishing a debut story collection is through the literary contests like AWP (that's how I got my start, as no agent was interested in my stories). But back then, most programs, like mine, were fully funded, so you went to school for free and got some university teaching experience.

I adjuncted for years and could never get an interview for a tenure-track teaching job. The constant rejection gave me an "I'll show them" mentality that helped me to make a living as a writer for about twenty years. A lot of it, of course, was timing, a huge part of it was my agent's finesse at securing foreign and film deals, and some degree of it was probably stubbornness.

I lived in San Francisco, which had a big literary scene (including of course McSweeneys) and still does. I remember being at a party where an extremely egotistical poet who happened to be a Stegner Fellow was name-dropping left and right about this party and that, and I remarked that hanging out with other writers was great unless it kept you from actually writing. He gave me a withering look and said, "I guess that means you're not going to --'s party." His point was that I wasn't invited and wasn't one of the cool kids. I don't remember the poet's name, but the woman whose party he was referring to published one story collection and hasn't published anything in the two decades since.

The point being that the writers who keep writing and who figure out how to carve a space for it, as both of you have done, are the ones who manage to make a way in the world as writers. Whether it's on Substack, with traditional publishers, or independently publishing, it comes back to sitting down alone and doing the writing, caring about the writing, insisting on writing when it would be more fun or more cool to do something else. There's no substitute for that.

Marc Watkins's avatar

Substack certainly has its problems, but it’s one of the few examples where long form writing and audience building have thrived.

24 more comments...

Ready for more?